Sports Card Shops in St. Catharines
St. Catharines, Ontario has 2 sports card shops listed on Sports Cards Near Me. Local listings include Hockey, Magic, and Other. All 2 carry a public Google rating, averaging 4.7 out of 5. Use the interactive map on this page to compare locations and get directions to the shop nearest you.
Ranks first: High Score Gamez — 4.9 stars from 86 Google reviews. Ordered by rating weighted for review volume, among shops with 20+ reviews — so this is not simply the highest star average. Nobody pays for a place in this ranking.
2 shown
High Score Gamez
40 Hartzel Rear, St. Catharines, ON L2P 1M5
★ 4.9 (86 Google reviews)
- Sells
The Toy Trove
280 Geneva St Rear Unit, St. Catharines, ON L2N 2E8
★ 4.4 (417 Google reviews)
- Sells
- Trade Nights
- Hockey
- Magic
- Other
- Pokemon
The interactive map needs JavaScript (and a map key) — every store below is fully browsable without it.
Upcoming card shows in Ontario
FAQ
- How many sports card shops are in St. Catharines?
- St. Catharines has 2 sports card shops listed on Sports Cards Near Me, with High Score Gamez ranking first at 4.9 stars from 86 reviews.
- Do any St. Catharines card shops buy collections?
- None of the St. Catharines shops listed here currently advertise buying collections. Check the Ontario page for other cities that do. Ontario page
- Do St. Catharines shops sell Pokémon cards?
- Yes — The Toy Trove carries Pokémon cards in St. Catharines. See Pokémon shops in St. Catharines
Directory data refreshed daily.
Keep looking
Nearby cities
Guides for collectors
- Pokémon & TCG Shops in Canada
How many shops in our sports card directory also carry Pokémon and other trading card games, and where.
- Are My Old Hockey Cards Worth Anything?
The honest answer for most 1990s cards, why the "junk wax era" happened, and which old hockey cards actually are valuable.
- Your First Card Show: What to Expect
What actually happens at a Canadian card show, how to handle cards politely, cash vs. card, and how to spot a real deal.